In the end, who deceived? The woman claimed to have been cheated 1 million 500 thousand for 10 years.

category:Society click:334
 In the end, who deceived? The woman claimed to have been cheated 1 million 500 thousand for 10 years.


Nu-2 for money, suspected of falsifying Wechat chat records, told the police that she was cheated 1.5 million yuan, police will Nu-1 arrested. Later, some people got 1 million 500 thousand yuan from the mother of female No.1 in the name of helping others. However, this huge sum did not rescue Angelita Li, and she was eventually pushed into prison.

Unfortunately, this is not a movie. Its the real thing happened to Angelita Li.

In 2016, Angie Lee was arrested, December 28, 2017, the Beijing Xicheng District Court made a first-instance judgment on the case: to fraud sentenced to 10 years in prison. Angelita Li and his mother refused to accept the appeal. On September 14, 2018, the Second Intermediate Peoples Court of Beijing held the second instance. The judge pronounced in court that the case of Angie Lee was sent back for retrial.

Lis mother, who is suffering from cancer, said that her biggest wish for the rest of her life was waiting for her daughter to regain her freedom.

Event playback

Whats more different from many girlfriends is that they often have large capital exchanges. Angie Lee has her own clothing company, and she is also doing consignment shopping abroad. Zhang Xinyue often looks for her to buy things, and often borrows money from her. Sometimes, Zhang Xinyue said that it was inconvenient for her parents to transfer money to her. She also made special transfers from Angie Lees account. Then she was given by Angie Lee. Sometimes the single fund was as high as several hundred thousand yuan.

With her boyfriend, or a traffic accident, or a poke in the basket, Zhang Xinyue is always the first time to seek the help of her girlfriend, perhaps in her opinion, this girlfriend is as close as her parents.

However, the two girlfriends feelings ended in March 2016. Until Angie Lee was arrested by the police, still can not believe that Zhang Xinyue alarm to arrest her, until she was in prison, completely believe that all this happened..

Why did two girlfriends who had known each other for seven or eight years suddenly turn their heads around?

Jin Yun news reporter found that all this seems to be related to a word: money.

In March 28, 2016, Zhang Xinyue reported to the Beijing Municipal Public Security Bureau Xicheng sub Bureau. In April 5th of the same year, Angelita Li was taken away.

Zhang Xinyue reported the case on the grounds of fraud. After Angie Lee was arrested, she provided the police with a large number of Wechat chats as evidence and some electronic information, such as bank pipelining, in an attempt to prove that Angie Lee cheated her by 1.5 million yuan.

According to Zhang Xinyues statement, Angie Lee registered four wechat names, impersonating her classmates sister, fortune-teller, Zhang Xinyues boyfriend, Yuan Mouyu, and her sister, Yuan Moqi. On many occasions, Zhang Xinyue or her family members were in trouble to collect money for disaster relief, totaling 1.5 million yuan.

On December 28, 2017, the Xicheng District Court of Beijing made a first-instance judgment on the case: Li Anqi was sentenced to 10 yearsimprisonment for fraud. The court found that from November 2015 to March 2016, Angie Lee used Weixin to fabricate multiple people to communicate with the victim and defrauded the victim of more than 1.2 million yuan.

first-instance judgment

The court also found that on March 24, 2016, Zhang Xinyue was found cheated and confronted with Angie Lee, who returned 595,000 yuan that day. In April 27th of the same year, Angelita Lis mother paid 800 thousand yuan to Li Xiangzhang.

Roger Nissim

It is not logical for Angelita Li to divide four corners with one player.

According to normal logic, if a person has four micro-signals, these four micro-signals want to communicate with a person at the same time, must be equipped with four mobile phones, but Angie Lee only has two mobile phones, that is, she must constantly switch Weixin landing account at the same time. If you log in with the mobile phones authentication code, the phone will receive the authentication code, which will leave a lot of traces on the mobile phone, Wechat system. However, the prosecution and the plaintiff did not have enough evidence to prove that Angelita Li was alone in four corners.

Where did Angelita Lis cell phone go?

The identification report shows that Angelita Lis mobile phone has registered many peoples WeChat, including Zhang Xinyue. Angie Lee said many times that Zhang Xinyue and her boyfriend Yuan Muyu knew the secret code of her cell phone and often used it. However, the evidence provided by Tencent Inc shows that Yuan Mouyu did not log in on WeChats mobile phone.

It is worth mentioning that after the case, Angie Lees mobile phone did not arrive, the public security organs gave the explanation is: because Angie Lees mobile phone was not identified as a crime tool, so not detained. In addition, Zhang Xinyue refused to provide mobile phones to the public security organs on the grounds of personal privacy in his mobile phone. The above chat records were printed and submitted to the public security organs.

Is Zhang Xinyue boyfriend real?

Zhang Xinyues confession mentioned that she had never met her so-called boyfriend Yuan Mouyu in the chat record and that four people, including Yuan Mouyu, were impersonated by Li Anqi.

But Angie Lees mother said in an interview that Zhang Xinyue told the police that Yuan introduced them to each other by Angie Lees classmates sister. Zhang Xinyues vast chat record shows that she is close to a netizen, both sides call each other husband and wife, and has certain economic contacts.

The evidence provided by Li Mu shows that Zhang Xinyue once said that her boyfriend Yuan was the son of a coal owner. There is evidence that Zhang Xinyue had visited her boyfriend in Taiyuan, Shanxi Province, before reporting the case. She once drove back and forth, but she crashed the car in the middle of the journey and borrowed money from Li Angqi to repair it.

At the same time, the two cases were completely contrary.

Xu Xin, Lis defense lawyer, said that Li was first interrogated at Guangwai Police Station of Beijing West City Branch from 17:10 to 21:38 on April 5, 2016. But he found two statements, one admitting fraud and the other denying fraud, which were identical in time and personnel, but totally opposite in content.

However, at the time of the trial, the time of the two confessions was changed, one to 17:10-19:00, the other to 19:10-21:38, and the page number was altered. According to the regulations, procuratorial personnel and investigators have no right to make amendments directly on the files, so the two transcripts can not be used as the basis for the final decision.

Xu Xin thinks that there is a problem in the transcript, which needs reasonable explanation.

Contradictory contradiction

Who asked Li mother for 1 million 500 thousand?

Angie Lees mother told a Jinyun news reporter that after she was arrested by the police, a policeman had given her a note with the telephone number and name. Angie Lee also mentioned the matter to the acting lawyer at that time, but the acting lawyer ignored it.

Later, Li received a phone call from Lee, who claimed to be a police handling case, and the other said he could help solve this problem. Soon, Li received another phone call from a car lawyer, and two people met.

Che showed her certificate and claimed to be entrusted with handling the case. If Li paid 1.5 million yuan, she would be released. Subsequently, Li Mu made a deposit of 800,000 yuan to Zhang Xinyues account, paid 700,000 yuan in cash to Chemou and signed a settlement. However, money was given, but Angelita Li did not regain his freedom.

Settlement agreement

Letter of understanding

800 thousand yuan transfer record involved in the settlement agreement

Lack of evidence for rush filing

Xu Xin said that Zhang Xinyues case was filed on March 28, 2016, and the West City Branch on April 5, 2016. The case was filed on the basis of no evidence other than Zhang Xinyues report on March 28, the screenshot of the letter submitted on March 30 and the bank running water transferred by the public security organ on March 29.

The first priority of filing a case is to believe that there is a criminal fact, which must be confirmed by evidence. Xu Xin believes that the evidence in this case is obviously insufficient.

Therefore, Xu Xin believes that the case is clearly eager to file a case, or even illegal filing.

In addition to the previous Zhang Xinyue provided a large number of chat records mentioned in the Bai (Zhang Xinyue ex-boyfriend) to help file the case, so that the case more doubtful.

Zhang Xinyue submitted a chat record shows that Zhang Xinyue said to Angelita Li, Bai Mou to find a relationship filing.

In the end, who owes the money?

The survey found that Angelita Li and Zhang Xinyue did have frequent economic exchanges. Zhang Xinyue has no formal job. Her parents are all in Inner Mongolia. Her father is a government department cadre. Regardless of her family background or income base, she can not afford Zhang Xinyues high expenditure. Zhang Xinyue has been demolishing the east wall to mend the West wall. Zhang Xinyue once told Angelita Li that her mother sold a house in Yanjiao, and 800 thousand of them were in her hands. Her father gave her a job in Beijing and gave her 500 thousand yuan. The money was spent by her, but she dared not let her parents know. In early 2016, Zhang Xinyue once said that his mother was going to visit her in Beijing. She was worried that her parents would ask about money.

Xu Xin introduced that Zhang Xinyue listed her own transfer account shows that she has transferred more than 600,000 yuan to Angel Lee. Angelita Li transferred to Zhang Xinyue more than 80 yuan of money. So calculated, Zhang Xin Yue owed Angelita Li more than 20.

Zhang Xinyue was used to being big-handed and had borrowed money from Angie Lee many times, even from herself, Li Mu said.

Zhang Xinyue used to borrow money from Angelita Li and Lee ma.

Is Zhang Xinyue suspected of perjury?

Xu Xin said that Zhang Xinyue submitted a chat record there are problems, normal chat record screenshots have ID, time, contact, micro-signal, status, type, message.

Zhang Xinyue submitted chat record but no micro-signal column, if Zhang Xinyue false evidence, she will constitute perjury.

The chat record submitted by Zhang Xinyue and the chat record provided by the counsel. It can be seen that in the record taken by the same software, the difference between the two is micro signal.

Latest progress

The second instance adjudged the case in court: the case was sent back for retrial.

Judgement of second instance

On the evening of September 13, Xu Xin rushed back to Beijing from abroad to study the case with the lawyer team and Li Mu and others until late at night. Early in September 14th, a group of people rushed to the second intermediate peoples Court of Beijing.

When Jinyun journalist met Li Mu in court, she said she was extremely nervous and didnt know what would happen later, but she firmly believed her daughter was innocent. Over the past two years, she has been to many places for petitions, complaints, even to the Supreme Court, staff members have exception received her, gave relevant advice, and gave her a strong belief.

Before the court session, there was a little interlude. Xu Xins lawyer is ready to connect to the computer data line, but the court staff said: No, the reason will soon be known.

At 10:00, the Court opened the court, and the clerk first read the court discipline. Subsequently, the judge said the direct sentence, everyone present was very shocked. Li Mu recalled that her heart was all about her voice, and her heart almost collapsed. In her view, there was no other process in court, and the direct sentencing might mean maintaining the original sentence, so Angel Lee would be wronged.

Angelita Li walked into the courtroom and looked at Xu Xins face. Li Mu felt that Angie Lees face was obviously swollen and she was obviously crying. She sat in the auditorium and was not sure whether her daughter had seen her, but she kept staring at Angie Lee and never looked away from her. Angelita Li kept staring at Xu Xin, and she looked very nervous when she was about to sentence. Xu Xin nodded to her in the distance and told her, dont be nervous.

Soon, the judge pronounced the case in court: the case was sent back for retrial.

After the trial, Xu Xins application for a few words with Angie Lee was rejected; Angie Lees mother wanted to speak to her, but also rejected. The judge said that he could then go to the detention center to meet and not to speak in court.

After leaving the courtroom and getting the verdict, Li mother breathed a sigh of relief. In her view, the second trial just so sentenced, is the first trial doubts, which means that the daughter is expected to regain freedom.

She consulted with Xu Xin and went to the peoples Court of Xicheng District to apply for bail pending trial.

Angelita Lis mother (right), lawyer Xu Xin (middle)

Li Mu said that two years after the case, she deeply realized what is a night of white, what is despair of life, what is the re-ignite of hope for life. Previously, she had been found to have cancer, and the operation was unsuccessful, causing the cancer to spread. She said her greatest wish for the rest of her life was to see her daughter free again.

The reporter contacted Zhang Xinyues mother and hung up the phone after he was informed of the intention of the interview.

Defense lawyer: the outcome of the second instance is expected.

Xu Xin, Lis defense lawyer, told Jinyun News that he would plead innocent for her. Xu Xin mentioned that Zhang Xinyue, the so-called victim and key witness, should have appeared in court for correction, but did not appear at the first instance, which is not in line with common sense. Therefore, before the second instance, the court was summoned to Zhang Xinyue for confrontation in court. But we still do not see anyone.

Xu Xin was a bit surprised when he pronounced the sentence in court. He said, because the notice was written in court. However, he was not surprised by the verdict of retrial. When he met with Angelita Li a few months ago, he said that the biggest possibility of the case was to send a retrial.

The judgment of sending back the retrial in the second instance means that the court of first instance is wrong, so the judgment of first instance should be cancelled and retried. Generally speaking, the facts are not clear or the procedure is seriously illegal, and the second instance will make such a decision. In this case alone, it is obvious that the facts are not clear enough and must be sent back for retrial. The judgment of second instance also means that the future Angelita Li case will develop in favor of her. In Xu Xins opinion, there is ample evidence that Angelita Li is innocent. Next, in addition to applying for bail pending trial, they are prepared to communicate with the Xicheng District Procuratorate, hoping that the procuratorate can take the initiative to withdraw the prosecution. Source: Jinyun editor: Ji Guo Jie _NBJ11143

The judgment of sending back the retrial in the second instance means that the court of first instance is wrong, so the judgment of first instance should be cancelled and retried. Generally speaking, the facts are not clear or the procedure is seriously illegal, and the second instance will make such a decision. In this case alone, it is obvious that the facts are not clear enough and must be sent back for retrial. The judgment of second instance also means that the future Angelita Li case will develop in favor of her.

In Xu Xins opinion, there is ample evidence that Angelita Li is innocent. Next, in addition to applying for bail pending trial, they are prepared to communicate with the Xicheng District Procuratorate, hoping that the procuratorate can take the initiative to withdraw the prosecution.