Because of a few drops of water, the man spat out blood and died suddenly. The family claimed 770000!

category:Hot
 Because of a few drops of water, the man spat out blood and died suddenly. The family claimed 770000!


There used to be people on the Shanghai subway

Because of a wet umbrella

But its unexpected,

On a rainy morning, many middle-aged and elderly people gathered in Shanghai Hongkou Football field to exercise. Some people hung their raincoats on the stair railings, and the raincoat dripped on Mr. and Mrs. Wangs clothes. Mr. and Mrs. Wang and his wife went to discuss the matter, and there was a dispute between them.

More than ten minutes after the situation subsided, Mr. Wang suddenly fell to the ground and died after he was sent to hospital.

Accidents caused by raincoat dripping

The family of the deceased took the case to court

Who is responsible for this?

Recently, the peoples Court of Hongkou District of Shanghai tried this case of right to life dispute in public, and finally determined that the deceased party should bear the main responsibility for the consequences of death, and Mr. Yuan and other three people involved in the incident should bear the secondary responsibility, and rejected other claims of the family members.

Family members claim 770000 for sudden death after a quarrel caused by raincoat dripping

7:00 am, January 4, 2019

Mr. Wang and his wife, Ms. Zhang

Its near the grandstand on the second floor of Hongkou Football field

physical exercise

It was raining

Suddenly my heart was unhappy

After a quarrel

Mr Wang joined the dispute

And then it leads to verbal gap and physical contact between several people

More than ten minutes after the two sides subsided, Mr. Wang suddenly fell to the ground

The patient died on the same day

Mr. Wangs wife, Ms. Zhang: I told him to not respond, so I turned him over and saw the blood gushing out like this, and his face was full of blood. I knelt down and pressed him on my chest to breathe, but I couldnt press it. I called and a woman who passed by helped me make a call.

It was identified that Mr. Wang died

And coronary atherosclerosis

Sudden cardiac death

Court: Mr. and Mrs. Wang are responsible for the sudden death

After hearing the case, the court held that in this case, Mr. Yuan and other three people really could not foresee the possibility of Mr. Wangs sudden death, and subjectively, they could not pursue the consequences of Mr. Wangs death. Moreover, Mr. Wangs emotional agitation caused by the infringement act involved in this case is only one of the possible causes to aggravate Mr. Wangs heart burden, induce his underlying diseases and then lead to sudden death. Therefore, the court held that Mr. Yuan, Ms. Tu and Mr. Yao should bear secondary responsibility for Mr. Wangs sudden onset and sudden death.

Secondly, Mr. Wang suffered from hypertension for many years before his death. It can be seen that Mr. Wangs own basic disease is the main cause of his sudden death. As Mr. Wangs spouse, Ms. Zhang knew that she was suffering from hypertension. Instead of dissuading and alleviating the conflict, Ms. Zhang argued with Mr. Yuan and other three people in the incident. This also stimulated Mr. Wang to react fiercely, and Mr. Wang himself ignored it. Therefore, Ms. Zhang and Mr. Wang themselves should bear the main responsibility for Mr. Wangs sudden death.

Thirdly, in this case, the Hongkou Football field has a large field and a large number of people do morning exercises. The time of dispute between the two sides is relatively short. More than ten minutes after the situation subsided, Mr. Wang fell to the ground until his sudden death. It is obviously unreasonable to require the management staff to keep on guard at all times and to respond to emergencies immediately. Moreover, after the 110 and 120 attendance, the security personnel also assisted in guiding Therefore, the management of Hongkou Football field has done its duty to actively rescue the risk and prevent the expansion of losses.

(function(){( window.slotbydup=window .slotbydup||[]).push({id:u5811557,container:ssp_ 5811557, async:true }Finally, the court held that Mr. Yuan, Ms. Tu, and Mr. Yao were jointly and severally liable for compensation, and the total amount of compensation was 47000 yuan for the medical expenses, death compensation, spiritual damage consolation money and attorneys agency fee of Mr. Wangs family members, but the rest of the lawsuit of the deceaseds family members was not supported. Source: Shanghai Legal Daily is a comprehensive collection of Shanghai legal news, dongfang.com.cn.source: responsible editor of southeast.com: Zeng Xi_ SHS1708

Finally, the court held that Mr. Yuan, Ms. Tu, and Mr. Yao were jointly and severally liable for compensation, and the total amount of compensation was 47000 yuan for the medical expenses, death compensation, spiritual damage consolation money and attorneys agency fee of Mr. Wangs family members. The rest of the lawsuit of the deceaseds family members should not be supported.

Source: Shanghai legal news is from Shanghai legal news, dongfang.com