Investigation of Chinese businessmen ufe31 the hospital hired medical trust to cheat patients to buy medicine in Xijing Hospital

category:Hot
 Investigation of Chinese businessmen ufe31 the hospital hired medical trust to cheat patients to buy medicine in Xijing Hospital


On April 6, Mr. Bao, a Yulin native, called the hotline 029-88880000 of the Chinese business daily for help, saying that when his mother was waiting in line to see a doctor in Xijing Hospital, a woman about 50 years old claimed to be a patient and actively approached the old man to talk about her illness.

Mr. Baos mother said she was often dizzy, especially when she got up quickly. Hear this, this woman says, giddy take western medicine cannot remove root, her a relative also has this disease, took Chinese medicine to be good. After chatting for more than half an hour, the woman said that she could not see her number that day, so she had to come back another day. Her family lived in the south of the city, but she could take Mr. Baos mother to the clinic where his relatives went to see the doctor.

Later, they took a taxi to Xian Yanta Tongjitang clinic, No. 4, West Mingde road. After the doctor asked about their condition, they took several drugs. The drug list showed a total of 2000 yuan. After grasping the medicine and looking for the good Samaritan, the other side had already disappeared.

Feeling cheated, Mr. Baos mother immediately contacted his family. According to the old mans description, the family knew that they had met a medical trust. Mr. Bao asked for help from the Chinese business newspaper and called the police. Later, accompanied by his family, he went to the Yanta Tongjitang clinic. After coordination, he asked for more than 2000 yuan back.

Go to see a doctor with two female patients

Wechat is blackmailed after drug application

Ms. Li, from the rural area of Southern Shaanxi Province, reported that her 18-year-old brother had a long-term headache. When she brought her brother to Xijing Hospital for examination, she met a strange woman who took the initiative to talk with her, saying that her son was almost the same age and had the same symptoms. She spent tens of thousands of yuan in other hospitals and had no effect. At last, she went to the TCM outpatient department of Shaanxi medicine group to cure the disease. During the conversation, another woman beside said surprisingly that she had a headache for a long time. If the effect is good, she would also like to see it. They kept chatting about the treatment effect, expert team, etc. and turned on the mobile phone navigation to check the location, and then asked Ms. Li to go together.

Several people took a taxi to the third floor of the TCM outpatient department of Shaanxi medicine group. At that time, the doctors gave them 15 doses of traditional Chinese medicine, 963 yuan. After grasping the medicine, Ms. Li found that one of the two women who had come together had disappeared; the other was holding the prescription, but the official seal of financial charges was not stamped on it. She put the prescription on the front desk and said that she would come to pick up the medicine in the afternoon, but she also disappeared. Later, when Ms. Li contacted the two good Samaritans via wechat, she found that she had been blackmailed by the other party.

After the event, under the coordination of the reporter of the Chinese business daily, a dean surnamed Zheng from the outpatient department of traditional Chinese medicine came and returned the full amount. For the two medical trusts, the Dean did not mention anything.

Doctors say a dozen drugs will cure the headache

Be intimidated to mind your own business after seeing through the fraud

On May 11, Ms. Ning went to Xijing Hospital to see a doctor because of her headache. She met two women and asked them to talk to her. She said that her headache could only be cured by taking traditional Chinese medicine, and she knew a well seen TCM clinic. Unable to resist persuasion, the three of them took a taxi to Xian Weiyang Kangcheng hall TCM clinic in Chanba peninsula. The doctor said that more than a dozen drugs can cure the disease and prescribe a prescription, which needs more than 3000 yuan. At that time, Ms. Ning didnt bring enough money, so she called a relative in Xian who was engaged in medical equipment. After getting to know the situation on the phone, relatives immediately took a taxi to stop the act and reported it to the hotline of China business daily.

No pulse

The doctor said, you can judge almost at a glance

In these complaints, the cheated mostly focus on the cervical, lumbar, dizziness and other symptoms. The reporter went to several TCM clinics and massage shops to experience the above-mentioned patients.

The reporter proposed that traditional Chinese medicine does not advocate calling for the pulse before visiting the patients condition? According to the doctor, he is an old expert and can judge almost at a glance. At the request of the reporter, the doctor said after the pulse, we need to prescribe several drugs, first treat kidney deficiency, then treat liver fire. After these two treatments, the cervical vertebra and dizziness will be good. While talking, the doctor is busy prescribing medicine.

There is an ancestral liquid for the treatment of cervical spondylosis

Its better to have long-term treatment with card

On the afternoon of May 7, the reporter came to the lanluo hall opposite to the remaining town vegetable market in Wuyi District, which is carrying forward the traditional Chinese medicine and the traditional Chinese medicine. It was clearly written in the shop that our masseuse has obtained the national massage qualification after formal study, and on the other wall hung various ancestral secret recipes for treating cervical vertebra, periarthritis of shoulder, lumbar vertebrae, sciatic nerve and characteristic health preservation.

The reporter said that cervical vertebra was not very comfortable. A middle-aged woman who claimed to be a doctor gently pressed her hand. She said that cervical spondylosis would be associated with lumbar pain, which should be caused by long-term inactivity. She needed to open the venation and acupoints. First, she needed to scrape through to treat moisture. She needed to use their ancestral medicine and unique treatment. After long-term treatment, she could be cured. Its best to apply for a card.

Later, the doctor took out a bottle of liquid, saying it was unique to them and could not be bought outside. For the origin of the ancestral secret recipe, the woman did not answer positively. The reporter asked if she had a medical qualification certificate. The woman said she had a senior masseuse qualification certificate. The reporter wanted to see her senior masseuse qualification certificate, but she didnt provide it all the time, just kept urging the reporter to pay for the card.

On May 8, the reporter came to Taoyuan road as a patient, playing the ancestral treatment of cervical spine brand store. A middle-aged man who claims to have graduated from the University of traditional Chinese medicine first worked in the hospital and then took over the ancestral skills to open the shop here. He pressed the reporters cervical vertebra and said that cervical spondylosis has been a long time. The left side is seriously ill, which will extend to the lumbar spine and legs. Over time, it will affect walking and lead to heart disease. He asked the reporter to lie on the bed, massage and diagnose the situation, saying that the condition was very serious. Only by external massage and internal oral administration of ancestral secret medicine can the patient be cured. It took more than three months before and after, each course of treatment was more than 3000 yuan.

The doctor said that when they treat cervical spondylosis, they have ancestral skills and can be eradicated within three months. Then he took out a small bottle and said it was the secret oral medicine of his family. When he saw that there was no label on the bottle, the reporter suggested that it was not safe to have no production license. The doctor said: if the label is clear, what is the ancestral secret medicine.

Then the doctor said he had a unique massage technique, massage the cervical vertebra and lumbar leg. During half an hours massage, he kept promoting oral medicine. After the massage, the reporter didnt feel relaxed, but the neck and shoulders were painful, dry mouth, headache and nausea. The reporter says unwell, this doctor says, just begin to contact massage treatment so, rest is good. That night, the reporters pain intensified. The next day, he went to the regular hospital for treatment. The doctor said it belonged to the category of muscle strain. The pain was relieved after 3 days rest.

Suspected aggravation of the childs condition after treatment

The doctor said, dont open your mouth and say theres something wrong with the medicine.

Parents said that the child was 12 years old, and had once grasped traditional Chinese medicine since April 23, and once again on April 29. It turns out that the child has only a headache. Since taking this medicine, the child begins to have a seizure once or twice a day. Every seizure is similar to epilepsy. In the face of parents doubts, the doctor of this TCM clinic insisted on taking their medicine, and reminded parents not to open their mouth and say that there was a problem with the medicine.

After grasping the medicine, the family of three squatted at the door of the outpatient department. The father smoked with sad face, and the mother held the child helplessly. Several times, the reporter suggested that the parents could go to the regular hospital for treatment, but the two parents listened to the staff of the TCM clinic. The reporter once again tried to get close to the three members of the family and wanted to get their contact information. After being stopped by the staff of the TCM clinic, he took them away and never found them again.

Medical trust swindled the elderly with eye diseases

The reporter came to the hospital and was advised to leave

At 2:30 p.m. on May 14, at the gate of the traditional Chinese medicine clinic of kangchengtang in Weiyang, Xian, reporters saw three people getting on and off a taxi. Two middle-aged women helped an old man with eye disease to get off the car and come to the clinic. The reporter came to the TCM clinic as a patient. After the old man came to the clinic, he received the case registration accompanied by a middle-aged woman. The young man registered.

Because there is only one doctor in the TCM clinic, the reporter came to the doctors office with consultation as the origin. Seeing the old man sitting down after entering the doctors room, the reporter asked the old man, its hard to use your eyes. Why did the two women come in alone? Why didnt they come with you? The old man replied, I dont recognize them. Speaking, the head of TCM clinic (Northern Shaanxi accent) came to the doctors room to let the reporter leave, and asked the reporter, what are they doing in TCM clinic? How did you get here? How do you know about their hospital? What disease do you see? Get out of here!

At this time, two middle-aged women who accompanied the elderly in the front hall, one was sitting in a chair and playing with her mobile phone, the other was answering and making a phone call. The content of the speech was to introduce how to get to the hospital.

At 3:05 p.m. that day, the above-mentioned old man with eye disease went out of the traditional Chinese medicine clinic with a large bag of medicine after seeing the doctor, accompanied by two women. One woman was busy stopping a taxi, and the other accompanied by a taxi to the north station.

On April 17, the reporter asked Ms. Li, who had been cheated, to come to Xijing hospital again. Ms. Liu, with a northern Shaanxi accent and a canvas bag, went to the second floor alone after she separated from the reporter at the outpatient building of Xijing Hospital. About two hours later, Ms. Li called to meet the reporter in the inpatient department.

Ms. Li said that when she was lining up on the second floor, a middle-aged woman took the initiative to talk to her and asked her what she was suffering from. Instead, she asked, why didnt the man (reporter) who came with you go upstairs? What kind of relative is he in your family? Ms. Li said that she came to see a doctor alone, but the middle-aged woman said that she saw that she had come to the hospital with two people upstairs, only to see Ms. Li go upstairs alone, and then the middle-aged woman turned to leave.

>>>Explosive

Medical trust will also look, hear and ask

Mainly targeting out of town patients

According to the investigation of the reporter, when medical trust is attached to three hospitals, one is attached to a large hospital, which often appears here to win the trust of patients as patients friends; the other is attached to patients, mainly targeting patients from other places, finding out the source of disease, and cheating patients to see a doctor in some small clinics; the third is attached to each small outpatient clinic, and getting a commission through pulling peoples heads, which is less than tens of yuan and more than hundreds of yuan.

Mr. Meng introduced that the current medical care has formed a group, with clear division of labor, no money for deception and no money for deception. This kind of separated space crime has brought great difficulty to crack down on medical care. Mr. Meng said that there are dozens of medical trusts in the hospital. In general, three people can form a group, one person can chat up, take the initiative to get close to the patient, understand the condition, get trust, and instill the idea of changing the hospital; one person can cooperate, join in the discussion in time, and increase the trust; another person can watch to see if there is any law enforcement department or hospital security personnel to investigate and deal with, and more importantly, to ensure the occurrence of special cases The situation (patient dispute) appears in time with the onlookers, which makes the medical trust escape in time.

In order to ensure that the patients who are fooled can spend money to buy medicine, the medical trust will also participate in seeing a doctor and prescribing after bringing the patients to the hospital, because there are marks on the prescription, and the pharmacy will not actually collect money when the actual expenses are incurred. Even if the payment is made in front of the patient, the hospital will refund it in full.

Mr Meng said that in order to prevent the cheated from reporting, they usually pay special attention to the evidence chain. Public security organs also take evidence as the basis when attacking medical trust. Therefore, hospital Commission will be remitted to a third party, who will transfer it to medical trust according to oral agreement. In this way, once arrested, there is no money exchange, medical trust will insist that it is out of kindness, not medical trust.

Previously, the reporter interviewed the Security Department of Xijing Hospital, and the staff introduced that in order to crack down on these people, they also made strict inquiries through monitoring, but the daily flow of outpatients was too much to check one by one.

Medical trust can also look, smell, ask and cut. Hope refers to judging the identity of patients through their clothes and luggage, and choosing more remote rural areas rather than urban people; hearing, listening to where the accent comes from and what kind of disease they get; asking, asking about their condition, and winning favor through sympathy with each other; finding out the weakness of patients who are eager to cure and recover, and recommending other hospitals.

Medical trust is an organized activity in hospital. Once it is interfered by the hospital, it will resist. Because there is no clear legal basis, the hospital is often difficult to solve the problem.

>>>Remediation

The crime of separating space in medical trust

(function(){( window.slotbydup=window .slotbydup||[]).push({id:u6056789,container:ssp_ 6056789, async:true }According to Mr. Meng, the threshold for medical care is low and the implementation is simple, but the harm is great and it is difficult to obtain evidence. In view of the problems of medical trust and number traffickers, which are mainly reflected by the masses, several departments have jointly carried out special actions to rectify medical trust in the past few years. It is required that if it is found that it is suspected of medical trust activities, the health administrative department and the industrial and commercial administrative department shall respectively investigate and deal with the relevant medical institutions and Internet enterprises according to law. For the medical institutions that employ medical trust and other improper methods to recruit patients, we should explore to include the scores of bad practice in the medical institutions, and strengthen the punishment. But in the actual operation, at present, the non-medical practitioners who act as the medical trust fraud are punished by the public security organs according to the provisions of the law of public security management punishment. However, there are many problems such as the difficulty of investigation, the difficulty of obtaining evidence and so on. Especially now, it is more difficult to obtain evidence for the isolated crime of medical trust. Reporter she Huiwen / figure of China business daily source: responsible editor of China Business Daily: Hou Shuai_ NN5533

Mr. Meng introduced that the threshold for medical care is low and the implementation is simple, but the harm is great and it is difficult to obtain evidence. In view of the problems of medical trust and number traffickers, which are mainly reflected by the masses, several departments have jointly carried out special actions to rectify medical trust in the past few years. It is required that if it is found that it is suspected of medical trust activities, the health administrative department and the industrial and commercial administrative department shall respectively investigate and deal with the relevant medical institutions and Internet enterprises according to law. For the medical institutions that employ medical trust and other improper methods to recruit patients, we should explore to include the scores of bad practice in the medical institutions, and strengthen the punishment. But in the actual operation, at present, the non-medical practitioners who act as the medical trust fraud are punished by the public security organs according to the provisions of the law of public security management punishment. However, there are many problems such as the difficulty of investigation, the difficulty of obtaining evidence and so on. Especially now, it is more difficult to obtain evidence for the isolated crime of medical trust. She Huiwen, reporter of China business daily / photo