On April 12, 2019, there were media reports on 317 errors in a judgment of Hunan Higher Court over 200,000 mu of land, Behind 317 errors in a judgment of Hunan Higher Court: New evidence exposes the application of the highest prosecution for accepting protest.
The Hunan Provincial High Court responded that the case was a dispute between Changsha Jinxia Development and Construction Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as Jinxia Company) accepted by Hunan Provincial High Court, Changsha Transportation Bureau and the third person, Changsha Jiangwan Science and Technology Investment Group Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as Jiangwan Company), and the third person, Hunan Longqian Transportation Development Group Co., Ltd., on the transfer contract of state-owned land use rights. Case.
On December 11, 2014, the Hunan Provincial Higher Peoples Court issued a civil judgment (2013) No. 4 of the first name of Xianggao Famin. Jinxia Company and Jiangwan Company appealed to the Supreme Peoples Court. During the second instance, it was found that there were many errors in the verdict. On November 10, 2015, Hunan Provincial High Court corrected 23 errors in the verdict, including repeated errors. At the same time, it initiated the accountability procedure, dealt with the judges who undertook the case seriously and apologized to the parties.
In order to prevent this kind of situation from happening again, Hunan Provincial College of Higher Learning has carried out warning education in the whole hospital, taken a series of measures to ensure the quality of legal documents, and carried out regular case evaluation activities.
The Hunan Provincial High Court said that it would learn the lessons from the incident, further strengthen the style of work, pay close attention to the quality of handling cases, and strive to make the people feel fair and just in every judicial case.
60 mu of land changed to 200,000 mu? 317 mistakes in a judgment of Hunan Higher Court
More than 60 mu of land was transformed into 200,000 mu in the judgment, spanning four provinces; 38891407 yuan was awarded 38891407 million yuan, tens of millions of debts instantly rose to astronomical figures; Construction Bank 51 Road Branch replaced ICBC 51 Road Branch into a lawsuit. These errors came from a civil judgment issued by Hunan Provincial Higher Peoples Court on December 11, 2014. There were 317 errors in the 33-page verdict, with an average of 9.6 errors per page.