Ma dedicated not to appeal, and entrust a lawyer to obtain a written reply to the first author of the two forensic medical materials, which is based on the related theory - the first author of the textbook of forensic medicine: the nasal seams were separated to the fracture of the nasal bone. It is not that the nasal seams belong to the nasal bone fracture, but because of the related content, it is necessary to put it in a section. The next discussion. After the two written reply was submitted, the Kaifeng intermediate peoples court revoked the first instance and revoked the case. Ma Xianzhongs defender, Liu Changsong, told the surging news in May 4th. However, 9 months ago, there was no court hearing. To identify the problem, Kaifeng Public Security Bureau propaganda personnel to surging news, the case has reached the trial link, it is difficult to accept the interview. Tongxu County Peoples court propaganda staff said to the surging news that the court will be held as soon as possible. Ma Xian Zhong has been released from prison in June 2017 and is still running around for his own case. Duan Yanchao map of an surging journalist Nasal separation was identified as a nasal bone fracture, and the defendant was sentenced. In March 20, 2017, the peoples Court of Tongxu County, with the crime of intentional injury, sentenced Ma to three months of imprisonment for one year and 4388 yuan for Ma Shuqins medical expenses. The verdict shows that the court heard that Ma Xian Zhong and Ma Shuqin had complained to the court about disputes arising from the sale of housing. In February 24, 2016, at 20, Ma Shuqin, his son Ma Kai, son in law sun Bao together to find the question of the house of Ma dedicated to the house, in a horse dedicated to the house, the two sides fought each other, Ma dedicated his fist to the nose of the horses nose. The degree of Ma Shuqin injury was identified as light injury two. In March 22, 2016, Ma was arrested by prison. The focus of the dispute was in the two injury judicial identification. According to the latest human injury degree identification standard, it is in line with fracture of the left nasal bone and the fracture of the frontal process of the left upper jaw before it can be identified as a minor injury grade two. On the day of the incident, Ma Shu Qin examined the peoples Hospital of Tongxu County, and the diagnosis was nasal bone fracture. 5 days later (March 1, 2016), Ma Shuqin went to the Kaifeng Central Hospital for examination. The diagnosis was left nasal bone branch and frontal maxillary frontal fracture. At the end of March 2018, the police of Tongxu County police station, Chengguan police station, Lin Yuyu, told the news. Because the diagnosis opinion of Tongxu County Peoples hospital only said the nasal bone fracture, not detailed, and the image was not clear enough, the forensic medicine of the Tongxu County Public Security Bureaus physical evidence identification room was commissioned by them, and the horse book service was also taken to the Kaifeng City Center Hospital for inspection. And according to the inspection results and analysis, issued an identification book that identified Ma Shu Qin as a minor injury grade two. According to this, Ma dedicated to imprisonment. In June 2016, Mas defender took the image of Ma Shu Qins CT examination at Kaifeng City Center Hospital, and went to the First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University to register Li Shuxin, an authoritative imaging expert in Henan province. The diagnosis was the left maxillary frontal fracture (edited note: no fracture of the left nasal bone branch). They handed over the diagnosis to Tongxu County Peoples Procuratorate, and the latter ordered the County Public Security Bureau to reappraise it. In reappraisal, the results of four hospitals were different from those of Kaifeng central hospital. Duan Yanchao map of an surging journalist Since then, Tongxu County Public Security Bureau Chengguan police station has commissioned the Kaifeng Municipal Public Security Bureau physical evidence appraisal institute to re appraise. In September 18, 2016, the examination and appraisal of the degree of forensic medical science of the Public Security Bureau of the Public Security Bureau of Kaifeng Municipal Public Security Bureau showed that the forensic and police officers took horses to the Kaifeng Second Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine, the first 55 Central Hospital of the Liberation Army, the Zhengzhou peoples Hospital, and the Zhengzhou peoples hospital. The doctor looked at the examination images of the peoples Hospital of Tongxu County on the day of the incident. The results of the diagnosis of the four hospitals had the left maxillary frontal fracture, but none of the left nasal bone branches were fractured. Of the three hospitals, the left nasal and maxillary suture was widened, which accords with nasal separation. The expert diagnosis of the left nasal maxillary suture and the left maxillary frontal fracture, the expert diagnosis of the left nasal maxillary fracture and the left nasal bone fracture and the left maxillary fracture after external injury. The fracture of the frontal process was two. In this regard, Mas defender questioned why four hospitals did not check the left nasal bone fracture, Kaifeng City hospital has been checked out? Nasal seperation is the gap between the two bones widened, fracture is a bone, how can the same? Police station in Chengguan police station Lin Yuyu told the surging news, specific to the hospital inspection, the County Public Security Bureau forensic identification room forensic contact, forensic medicine with a horse school to Kaifeng City Center hospital inspection, the police have not been together, because the time is too long, he can not remember. But when he was re identified, he went to four hospitals for examination. He went with the forensic medical expert of Kaifeng City Public Security Bureau, and he was also present at the expert consultation. However, he did not explain why the examination results of Kaifeng central hospital were different from those of the four hospitals. The defender obtained important evidence and was revoked in the first instance and returned to the retrial. According to the JINGWAH times, the famous forensic Hu Zhiqiang, as an expert assistant of the defense, pointed out during the trial of first trial, that in the medical and forensic circles, the separation and fracture of bone seams were two inconfuscation concepts. The left nasal maxillary seams belong to the nasal bone fracture obviously confused two people, and Hu Zhiqiang also took out ten. in court. There is a clear expression of clinical fracture forensics, which can not be used to diagnose fracture of nasal bone. However, the verdict of the peoples Court of Tongxu County shows that the appraisal opinion, according to the legal procedure, according to the relevant theory and the discussion by the imaging experts and the forensic experts, makes the appraisal opinion of the two level of light injury according to the legal procedure, and should be the basis of the case according to law. The defender and the person he applied with special knowledge believe that Ma Shuqins injury can not reach the two level of light injury. It is not accepted by the hospital according to a family word of a persons document. After the first trial, Ma Xian Zhong refused to accept the case and filed an appeal. He commissioned the agent to find two first forensic medical textbooks in June 2017. Two chief editors of forensic medicine wrote that nasal separation is not a fracture of the nasal bone. Duan Yanchao map of an surging journalist According to Prof. Weili, the individual believes that the fracture can be considered as a fracture after the fracture of the bone, resulting in a certain degree or dislocation due to external force, and if the fracture of the frontal maxillofacial fracture with the same side is separated from the bone seams of the nasal bone, it is actually a joint fracture injury. It is not necessary to use one fracture in two places; if the fracture of the nasal bone is separated on the side or other part of the frontal fracture of the maxilla, the fracture can be seen in the identification. It is emphasized by Professor Weili that forensic workers are certified according to the standards of identification, referring to the contents of the image, and not using this book as the basis for identification. Professor Li Songbai, the author of medical imaging and director of the radiology department of the First Affiliated Hospital of China Medical University, said the separation of the nasal seture to a small section of the fracture of the nasal bone does not mean that the separation of the nasal seture belongs to the fracture of the nasal bone. The separation of the nasal maxillary suture is only the separation of the nasal maxillary suture. It is not the nasal bone or the maxillary bone. Continuous fracture is not a fracture itself. Professor Li Songbai said that it was written in a small section because of the clinical examination of the nasal bone, and the separation of the nasal seture, including the nasal maxillofacial seture, and the diagnosis needed to be identified, so it was discussed together. Generalized nasal bone fracture also belongs to this range, but nasal separation is not a fracture of nasal bone. The two written materials were submitted to the intermediate peoples Court of Kaifeng City. In July 17, 2017, the court ruled that the facts of the first trial were not clear, revoked the first trial and returned to the retrial. In May 4th, lawyer Liu Changsong, a lawyer of Ma Xian, told the surging news that the case of Ma Xian Zhongs retrial was nearly 9 months ago. In June 21, 2017, Ma dedicated his sentence to be released. According to the provisions of the criminal procedure law, cases of retrial shall be tried in a separate collegial panel according to the procedure of first instance, and the case shall be heard in accordance with the procedure of first instance. The case shall be declared within 2 months after acceptance, at the latest not more than 3 months; (only) for cases that may be sentenced to death or with a civil lawsuit, the first class court approves the case. It can be extended for 3 months, and the extension of the case may be extended to the Supreme Peoples court for approval. Liu Changsong believes that the case is not yet in session and is suspected of being illegal. Liu Changsong told the surging news that at present, they put forward a series of applications to Tongxu County Peoples court. For example, the evidence for the forensic identification of the Tongxu County Public Security Bureau was only a CT report from Kaifeng City Center Hospital, while the victim Ma Shuqin was hospitalized at the peoples Hospital of Tongxu County. The victim was in court at the trial of first instance and said he had never left the hospital to Kaifeng during the hospital stay in the county peoples hospital. They suspected the CT report. It is only a forgery. It has applied for the complete registration of outpatient registration, doctor CT application form and CT electronic picture of CT inspection in Kaifeng Central Hospital, so as to restore facts. In addition, the Public Security Bureau of Kaifeng Municipal Public Security Bureau is a reappraisal institution. The institution of forensic medicine is called to organize two consultations of expert consultation, but two copies of the forensic identification center of the Public Security Bureau of the city of Kaifeng are discussed, and one expert signature has 4. An expert signature has 7 people, in addition to the appraiser Chen, another 6 people signed scribbled scribbled, unable to distinguish, also do not know their units, positions, contact methods, they also applied for the information to apply for their testimony. The two one discussed the experts signature on the record. Most of the notes were illegible, nor did the expert units and posts be written. Duan Yanchao map of an surging journalist Court trial records showed that Ma Shu Qin indicated that he had not been out in hospital during Tongxu County Peoples Hospital, nor was he taken to Kaifeng for examination. However, surging news in May 4th called Ma Shuqin, who said he had been out in hospital, to Kaifeng inspection is true. On the issue of identification, at the end of March 2018, the Public Security Bureau of Kaifeng City Public Security Bureau told the news that the case had come to the trial, and after communication with the identification of the material evidence, it was inconvenient to accept the interview. Tongxu County Peoples court propaganda staff said to the surging news that the court will be held as soon as possible. The source of this article: surging news editor: Huang Zhecheng _B9302 Court trial records showed that Ma Shu Qin indicated that he had not been out in hospital during Tongxu County Peoples Hospital, nor was he taken to Kaifeng for examination. However, surging news in May 4th called Ma Shuqin, who said he had been out in hospital, to Kaifeng inspection is true. On the issue of identification, at the end of March 2018, the Public Security Bureau of Kaifeng City Public Security Bureau told the news that the case had come to the trial, and after communication with the identification of the material evidence, it was inconvenient to accept the interview. Tongxu County Peoples court propaganda staff said to the surging news that the court will be held as soon as possible.